Italy orders Facebook consent changes, fines Meta €805m

Italy orders Facebook consent changes, fines Meta €805m

Add CyberWorldOpsto your preferred sources on Google
Italy orders Facebook consent changes, fines Meta €805m
Data Breaches

Illustrative image generated with AI

Meta must change how Facebook for Android obtains permission to suggest posts from users’ phone galleries after Italy imposed an €805 million fine on November 14, The Hacker News reported. Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante, gave the company 60 days to make the feature a separate consent choice and leave it switched off by default, including for users who previously allowed gallery access.

The regulator found that the default-enabled feature accessed Italian users’ photos, videos and associated metadata—information related to those files—without explicit consent. About 20 million Android users in Italy formed part of its assessment of the penalty. The Garante said the breach continued for users who had already granted permission and for those who had not updated the app.

Meta intends to appeal. The Hacker News cited a statement reported by Reuters in which a spokesperson described the penalty as “disproportionate.” The company’s position is that the feature operates only after users authorize access on their device and that they can withdraw that permission through settings at any time.

One permission, several purposes

The case turns on whether permission to open the gallery adequately explains what Facebook will do with that access. The Garante found that one app-wide permission covered several functions serving different purposes. Before that request, users saw a general notice about enabling other features, without a clear explanation that gallery suggestions would also become active.

With full permission, the app can read the entire photo archive, generally with continuing access. The report said users and the regulator cannot verify which information the app actually uses. A person allowing access for one Facebook function therefore faces a broader choice that also covers suggestions drawn from their gallery.

The Garante found this arrangement breached Article 122 of Italy’s Privacy Code, the national implementation of the EU’s ePrivacy Directive. Under that provision, information stored on a phone falls within a person’s private sphere: accessing it requires freely given, informed consent even if nothing is transmitted elsewhere and no harm results.

Meta sought to have Ireland’s data protection authority handle the matter. The Italian regulator rejected that argument because ePrivacy rules lack a one-stop-shop mechanism for placing such cases with a single authority.

How the penalty was assessed

Facebook has offered the suggestion feature since 2023. A complaint from Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti, a consumer protection group in Bolzano, prompted the investigation, which began in July 2025 and included technical analysis by the Garante.

The fine amounts to approximately 0.47% of the group’s global revenue. Beyond the number of users involved, the authority considered the duration of the breach, a 2019 decision against Meta and the company’s limited cooperation with the investigation. It credited changes introduced after the complaint, but judged them late and effective only for people who updated the app.

The inquiry did not cover the use of gallery material to train AI models, which Meta denies. A separate examination remains possible for another feature introduced in 2026 that permits cloud processing of gallery content—processing on remote servers.

What changes for Meta and users

Within 60 days, Meta must present a dedicated consent request explaining why the suggestion feature needs gallery access and how users can disable it. Earlier permission to access the gallery does not exempt users from the requirement to have suggestions off by default. If Meta misses that deadline, it cannot activate the feature for anyone lacking valid consent.

The company must also report to the Garante within 30 days on work begun and within 90 days on measures implemented.

Users can follow the advice Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti published on July 11, 2025: disable Facebook’s gallery suggestion settings and review the app’s access permissions on their phone.

Security dossiers

Read next

Sources

Back to home

Latest Cybersecurity News

All cybersecurity news →