Brothers acquitted in $25 million Ethereum fraud prosecution

Brothers acquitted in $25 million Ethereum fraud prosecution

Add CyberWorldOpsto your preferred sources on Google
Brothers acquitted in $25 million Ethereum fraud prosecution
Vulnerabilities

Illustrative image generated with AI

Anton and James Peraire-Bueno have been acquitted of charges arising from an alleged Ethereum transaction exploit that prosecutors said netted about $25 million in cryptocurrency in roughly 12 seconds. US District Judge Jessica G. L. Clarke found that the government had not proved material misrepresentations needed to support wire fraud and related convictions, MLex reported on November 16, 2026.

The case concerned traders whose private, pending cryptocurrency transactions were allegedly exposed and manipulated before being added to Ethereum’s blockchain, the shared ledger that records transactions. Prosecutors had characterized the scheme as the first of its kind to be charged.

The brothers, former Massachusetts Institute of Technology students, had already faced a trial that ended without a verdict. BleepingComputer reported on November 17 that jurors’ inability to agree on conviction or acquittal led to a mistrial a year before Clarke’s decision.

The alleged route from private transactions to stolen funds

The prosecution’s account centered on the machinery used to validate transactions and place them on Ethereum’s ledger. Rather than targeting individual account credentials, the brothers allegedly manipulated that process to gain access to private transactions awaiting completion and change transactions for their own benefit.

BleepingComputer’s description of the allegations identifies a vulnerability in MEV-Boost relay code, software involved in handling proposed blocks, or groups of transactions. Prosecutors said the brothers used “bait transactions” to identify traders to target, then exploited the flaw to make a relay disclose a proposed block’s complete contents too early.

With that information, they allegedly rearranged the proposed block to favor themselves. Prosecutors said the subsequent reordering on Ethereum transferred approximately $25 million in cryptocurrency from the targeted traders.

Preparation took months, despite the brief execution time alleged by prosecutors. BleepingComputer placed the beginning of preparations in December 2022. The brothers were accused of studying their targets’ trading patterns and combining their mathematics and computer science education with cryptocurrency trading expertise to develop the scheme.

Arrests and concealment allegations

The US Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York announced the indictment on May 15, 2024. Anton, then 24, had been arrested in Boston the day before; James, then 28, was arrested in New York that same day.

The indictment charged conspiracy to commit wire fraud, wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Each count carried a maximum prison term of 20 years upon conviction.

The Justice Department alleged that the brothers declined requests to give the cryptocurrency back. Its account also described preparations to disguise their identities and the proceeds through shell companies, multiple private cryptocurrency addresses and foreign exchanges. After the alleged exploit, prosecutors said, further transfers were intended to make the funds’ origin and ownership harder to trace.

Investigators also cited online searches made during planning, execution and the aftermath. Those searches allegedly concerned carrying out the exploit, concealing participation and locating exchanges with limited “know your customer” procedures—the identity checks exchanges use for customers. Other searches concerned cryptocurrency lawyers, extradition procedures and the offenses ultimately charged. BleepingComputer additionally reported prosecutors’ allegation that the brothers hired lawyers with expertise in those subjects.

Why the prosecution failed

Clarke’s reasoning addressed whether the trial evidence could sustain the specific charges, even when assessed in the government’s favor. In the passage published by MLex, she distinguished that question from judgments about the brothers’ morality or whether their conduct might have violated offenses prosecutors had not charged.

The decisive failure was proof of material misrepresentations during the scheme. On that basis, Clarke granted the motion and ordered “a judgment of acquittal” for both brothers.

Read next

Sources

Back to home

Latest Cybersecurity News

All cybersecurity news →